[quote name='buckythekat']*
Fringe (Season 1 Complete Box Set) [Blu-Ray/Brand New/Factory Sealed] - $5.50
emjaymj - are you new to lowballs or something? goomba has a ton of great feedback and dv8 himself has bid on stuff[/QUOTE]
Uuhhh what? I've bid on a few things myself so far, like I said, I trust Goomba and have dealt with him multiple times, I have like $750 worth of stuff being mailed to him as it is, and have both given and received feedback on prior deals with him, and you'd probably know at least half this stuff if you bothered to read whole posts (and if you did and it all still somehow went over your head, I apologize for the sarcasm, that's not how I typically treat the mentally challenged). Instead, like some comical sort of superhero, buckythekat puts on his cape and tights and attempts to come to the rescue oblivious to the fact that it's clearly not needed. I also really couldn't care less if this dv8 guy I've never heard of (I'm guessing at least a demi-god, as supposedly his endorsement is supposed to automatically mean something) has made bids on Goomba's stuf or not. Again, I've made bids, i DO in fact trust Goomba.
I have no doubts Goomba is an honest guy, even to a degree that's quite unusual these days. What I'm trying to get at though is that this particular practice is something I'd be horribly uncomfortable with
IF Goomba wasn't somebody I already trusted. So some sweeping appeal to the fact he has good feedback and can be trusted to send items out actually has absolutely
nothing to do with my concern, it has more to do with the fact that somebody could technically have the highest bid when the auction is supposed to end, but since nobody knows when this is except for the person running the contest, he could just decide right then to let it run a little longer (especially if, as I said, a big ticket item has some momentum going), essentially making it possible for the people who would have otherwise won to get screwed over.
Since it's Goomba, I have a lot more faith that he'll be doing things honestly, but there's many different possibilities left open due to this. For instance, especially since this is a forum-based auction, if he logs on 10 minutes after he intended the auction to end, and see's there's been a much bigger bid for something in the time between, not many people would be able to resist just slightly tweaking the auction end-time in order to take advantage of something that just sort of fell on their lap. If it was a total stranger running this, this slight technicality could be as severe as the seller playing favorites and telling certain people when the auction is going to end, allowing them to bid-snipe without much competition, but even though I can't ever really know who is capable of this, I still pretty much KNOW Goomba wouldn't just violate his principles like that, so I'm not worried about anything so extreme. Still, having a 3rd party who won't be bidding to either choose or (if the seller wants some strategic control over the when the end is set), simply tell them on the outset when the auction will end, but while I suppose this leaves a little wiggle room for shady practices, even though it would be less, it would almost undoubtedly be somebody I don't trust as much as Goomba. I trust very few people as much as I trust Goomba... lol. Some variation of this might be a good practice for auctions with a "secret end-time" in general. I think some of the various twitters apps or whatever that let you schedule messages for the future would help keep honest people in check, but I suppose not entirely useful against anybody intentionally deceitful. I suppose an even better way to do it would be to add slowly, one by one, characters that compose an encrypted string containing the time in one form or another, releasing the last character of the hash at the end of the auction for verification. Technically, such a hash code could even be generated now, it doesn't HAVE to be at the beginning of the auction..
What would be REALLY neat I think is an online tool for lowball auctions and such that generates a secret time within a given range (perhaps a 12 hour minimum or something), where even the seller isn't aware of the exact time, until it becomes publicly displayed either when the time is reached, or preferably at the very the end of the given range. I think something like that could make the auctions really fun - there could be a lot of bidding go on during the last day and the suspense would be crazy as the highest bid at the end of the last day isn't necessarily the winner. I know that sounds like a bad thing for the seller, but something like this would encourage people to put their maximum bids earlier on, because baby steps could make them lose the whole auction, and so the seller has the potential to get an even better prince in addition to what I believe would be a fun and very fair way of conducting such an auction.
And as much as I trust Goomba, I'm sure there are a lot of people who don't have any sort of history with him, so there's a possibility it might actually affect somebody's decision to bid. But in general I'm not intending any of this to be taken as seriously as it's been taken. I enjoyed thinking about some of the ideas I came up with. The time-capsule sort of solution would probably take a fair bit of work as I don't know if such a thing already exists, but md5 hash generators and other simple encryption tools are easily found all over the web.
(BTW, as far as being safe to say it's always best for the seller to go longer... not necessarily true! lol... if you end them early pretty much all the time people will start to take notice and bid accordingly. Then all of a sudden you let it run really late and you'll probably have your best auction ever!)