Keeping them. Honestly wish I had not bought 3 of them, but oh well. At the time, I felt Sony was too arrogant to take the time to bother bringing rumble back. Guess I was wrong. For the most part, I usually am only using 2 controllers at a time. Sometimes I'll get 4 of us here, but I think I can make do with 2 DS3s and use the SIXAXISs for when guests come over.