[quote name="Spokker" post="11828171" timestamp="1402356952"]Halo 3 and Halo 4 are on Xbox 360. Xbox Live will eventually be shut down by Microsoft if you try to connect with an Xbox 360 console, just as it was with the original Xbox and Halo 2.
Is this not something people think about?
I can understand the justification to shut down some multiplayer servers. Nobody is going to be playing NBA 2K6 right now. But if Halo 2 is popular enough to release it in a collection of Halo re-releases, then it's popular enough to continue supporting via Xbox Live.
Please tell me where the logic falls apart. This is just anti-consumer.[/quote]
Your logic falls apart that they would shut down a service making them money. The original Xbox had very few users left on it. It is hard to justify dedicating servers to a small user base. Even if one game is popular it isn't necessarily enough to keep an entire server farm in place. On top of that they wanted to add features to Xbox Live that they weren't capable of because Live was not designed to be modular on the original Xbox. Not forward thinking at the time, but they have since stated that they corrected that on 360 and going forward. So, as long as people are playing the games and using the system there isn't really much to worry about is there? Was I mad that I couldn't play Halo 2 online? No, because they had two sequels out since then with another on the way. If people are only playing Halo 4 on 360 then, yeah, they might shut it down. You want to play Halo 2 on og Xbox? Setup a tunnel service with your own server. Charge people even. How long do you think you'll be profitable? Maybe you can get Goodwill to run it, though, since you think Live is a charity.