[quote name='LinkinPrime']Most likely yes.
First of all, has the XBOX360 been able to play these 3 games before? If not, are they dirty or scratched? Actually come to think of it, either way, you would most likely need to call them. I've only had this issue with OXM discs in the past.[/QUOTE]
[quote name='sp00ge']Yup... that's what mine did. And the first replacement I received.[/QUOTE]
Yeah, DDR 2, Overlord and Mass Effect have been getting playtime everyday from one of us here.
But the good news, it's working again. I opened & closed the tray really quick (as in I hit it open and closed before it even open) and it began to read the discs. It also works when I turn on the 360. It hasnt messed up since. SO MAYBE, JUST MAYBE (and I'm being EXTREMELY optimistic right now) it was just a fluke and everything will be fine.