Stopped back in and made a quick list of more notable/odd things they had (ignored games like My Little Pony, Garfield, Megamind, Penguins of Madagascar and other movie/TV-baesd games):
YMMV - Extremely
(these prices INCLUDE the 50% off already taken)
Army of Two: 40th Day - $9.44
Binary Domain - $5
Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare - $9.44
Dead Island GOTY - $9.44
Dead Space 2 - $9.44
Dreamcast Collection - $5
Grand Theft Auto: Episodes from Libery City - $9.44
Halo 3 - $9.44
Halo Wars - $9.44
Need for Speed The Run - $9.44
Sonic Free Riders - $9.44
Supremacy MMA - $6.44
Tony Hawk Shred - $3.99
Top Spin 4 - $5
Warhammer 40,000 Space Marine - $5
Anarchy Reigns - $5
Arkham City GOTY - $9.44
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood - $5
Battlefield 3 - $9.44
Bulletstorm - $9.44
F1 2010 - $3.99
F1 Race Stars - $5
Fear 3 - $3.99
Grand Theft Auto IV - $9.44
Hitman Absolution - $6.44
Midway Arcade Origins - $9.44
Mortal Kombat vs DC Universe - $9.44
Need for Speed: Hot Pursuit - $9.44
NHL '11 - $3.99
Red Faction Armageddon - $6.44
Saints Row the Third - $9.44
Shift 2 Unleashed - $9.44
Timeshift - $3.99
W '12 - $9.44
Yakuza Dead Souls - $5
Wii Party w/ Wii Remote - $12.50
Stars Wars Episode III: The Clone Wars - $9.44
Drawn to Life: The Next Chaper - $7.50
Kung Zhu - $5
Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks - $7.50
Lego Chima: Laval's Journey - $9.44
Michael Jackson's the Experience - $7.50
Plants vs. Zombies - $9.44
Pokemon Ranger Guardian Signs - $7.50
Professor Layton and the Unwound Future - $7.50
Sonic Classic Collection - $9.44
Cubic Ninja - $5
Mahjong Cub3d - $5
Puzzler World 2012 - $5
Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell 3D - $5
How much was Spirit Tracks going for? If you go back, I'd be willing to buy it off of you or trade for it.
$7.50. Only reason I didn't immediately buy it is that my sister already owns the game (I think...need to double check on that).