Got mine in today and it clearly came from a store as it's got the spiderwrap indentations (and it also came from NY). Looks like the seals were already opened as well.
Guess I'll have to call tomorrow and complain, see if it gets me anywhere since it's not even on their website now.
Edit- Definitely opened before. Took the slip cover off and underneath it there's a quarter sized outward tear but no damage to the slipcover.
Edit Edit- Digging further the statue is clearly replaced in it's plastic thing and the sword just sort of sticking out the side. It's amazing it's not broken. Steelbook is awful sexy (and PS3 sized) but scratched and the codes are gone. Game disc has fingerprints on and a scratch on the bottom of it.
Starting to think this is a return that someone repackaged and an inattentive CSR just returned seeing that it still had seals on it. Typing this out and just seeing that the cardboard box that holds the game, book and flag has rips in it as well.