[quote name='shieryda']Laraque is a "smart" enforcer. Carcillo, on the other hand, is not.[/quote]
Agreed, however, Laraque's effectiveness has waned since the lockout, simply because a lot of the smaller guys, like Carcillo refuse to go with him. I look at it this way, when Matt Bradley throws an elbow at Sidney Crosby, I want someone to kick Bradley's ass, but he won't go with Laraque. Eventually, Laraque and Brashear would go for the umpteenth time, and the piper was never really paid. Now, I love watching those two drop, but I still want someone to wax Bradley. That's where Carcillo comes in.
I guess what I'm saying is that those two types of players aren't interchangeable, you know? But I'd rather not have stupid penalties...so it's a wash, I guess.