[quote name='banpeikun']All you have to do is tap A when the fish takes the bait. The easiest way is to go by the aural cue, the "plunk" sound. If you're watching the fish, you can get thrown off by a lot of the nibbles and ripples it makes. If you listen for the "plunk" though you won't get juked. You have a relatively small window of time to push A after that (probably around .4 seconds) but it varies from fish to fish.
Also, fish are harder to find in the DS version. On the GC, fish spawn every time you enter a screen, so everyone would find their favorite spot, catch a fish, leave, come back, and repeat. But on the DS it's not broken up into the different screens, so you have to walk around more. That and the funny perspective which can make the fish hard to see.[/QUOTE]
OK, thanks for the tip - HUGE difference. For one thing, I had to turn up the sound on my DS WAY higher than I have ever had it before to even hear the "plunk". Kind of annoying because now the music is blaring. Once I did that I caught 5 fish in a row (one little one seemed to be more sensitive than the others and got away). This is a big change from the GC version - there you pulled back as soon as the fish bit the first time. In AC:WW the fish are biting 4-5 times before taking the bait! So, basically, I was nearly always hitting 'A' WAY too early - I did it right after their first nibble. Now the museum is filling up fast

.
Thanks again! and you are right about the harder to find fish - that is what I was getting at in my previous posts. Only 2 fish in the ocean and maybe 3-4 spread the whole length of the river/pond/waterfall area. VERY sparse compared the the GC version. Oh well, now that I know how to catch the damn things it isn't too bad!