[quote name='Pure Apathy']We should just have a rule to decline all holding penalties on field goals until there is a fix out for it...[/QUOTE]
[quote name='Azumangaman']YES, I'm going to make that an official rule now in the OP.
DO NOT ACCEPT HOLDING CALLS ON FIELD GOALS!
So now bfauble is out, so there is an extra spot. I'll give priority to sstyler since I know he's legit from last year but MSUHitman can have the next opening. I'm heading off to advance the week now.[/QUOTE]
Wait what? I dont agree with that rule at all. There has to be a happy medium thats more fair than that.
Do I agree that there are too many holding calls on FG? Yes, but it happens to both teams seemingly at random. Also, holding calls to appear on FG attempts in real life as well.
I would be for not accepting multiple holding calls on FG (I have had it happen 3 times in a row on a extra point) but to say do no accept any is kinda bullshit. I have scored the most points in the entire league (only bringing that up to say this) so I have kicked the most extra points and the most FG in general and I have had two holding calls and you know what happened after my opponent accepted them? I kicked and made another FG. (one being a game winner)
The reason why I disagree with this rule is you are grossly taking out two main parts of football. Number one, it bails out the offense that has all the tools to simply get closer. If you are kicking from the 20 a 10 yard difference shouldnt do anything.
If you guys are worried about holding calls you should make sure you are close enough so getting one wont be a big deal.
Number two. If we were doing a draft you know who I would get in the 6 round? Rob Bironas. Why? Beacuse he can kick from 55 yards away. That rule basically makes all kickers the same. If you are worried about not making a long FG get a better kicker.
FG in madden have been embarrassingly easy for ten years. People have always been able to knock in 50 plus yard FG like nothing and I personal like the fact that you know have to think about where you are on the field before kicking a FG. Yes, I know that its slightly strange to have a holding call on a FG but I honestly have not seen that many and most of the time I just knocked in another one because I am never so far away that the 10 yards makes it impossible to hit.
That rules seems like a cop out to me because I dont understand why you simply cant kick another FG. Its not like you should miss it anyway....madden FG are embarrassingly easy to make and have been for forever the only real factor is the power of a kicker which like I said, if you cant make a 50 yard kick, get a better kicker or get closer like a team would do in real life.