[quote name='heybtbm']If it were only that simple. People with the new heatsink design (Elites or Premiums) can get the RRoD just like the unfortunate souls with the old "1 heatsink" design.
It all comes down to how much you play and how hard you work your 360. If it gets warm enough, it'll break. 2 heatsinks, 65nm chips..it doesn't matter if your 360 is working all day. People need to limit their playing time to 1-2 hour blocks then let the system cool down for another hour or two. Pathetic, but that's the reality MS engineers have left us to face. They never thought people would play their 360
all day long.[/QUOTE]
MS isn't
that stupid. They're pretty out there... but that admission would be a stretch even for them....
The problem existed, as I see it, in cost-cutting by MS and a faulty H/S design and heat exchange. They've since corrected that, redirected the heat properly, didn't skimp on the brackets holding the H/S down, and lo, the issue (I'd bet) disappears. Too early to tell, but I suspect they've nailed it down, or they wouldn't have taken the 1.5 billion dollar hit to repair consoles that exhibited this "feature".
Can someone induce the RRoD on a properly heatsink applied console? Sure... some people just don't get the idea of ventilation, and some people don't figure their 90 degree home is going to cause any ambient temp problems with their 360... these are the same people that complain their computers lock up all the time due to the very same heat that they can't figure out is causing problems with their console... and their plasma TV keeps bursting in the extreme heat... and of course plasmas "still suck"...
Sometimes you can't out-engineer the idiots.
Sure, you can overheat and possibly lock up your console if you're playing a marathon game of Gears, but not in the same manner as the GPU oozing off the mainboard... (permanent death of your console.)
Purely anecdotal comparison, but I played my previously old-heatsink design Premium hours upon hours in Oblivion (sometimes 7 hours at a whack, with 1 hour breaks where I paused the game at the menu), and then watched a movie on it (HD and/or DVD) with no trouble... and my new elite? I do the same thing (still playing Oblivion... hehehe).
Recall that we had a manufacturer try the "limit your time" with their product... that was IBM during the Deskstar Fiasco... they never admitted there was a problem... never recalled them... but quietly replaced most of them (under warranty) with better designed components.. then shortly thereafter sold their entire HDD division to Hitachi.
IBM had the audacity to say "up to 6 hours a day of HDD usage is common... anything more than that might cause a failure..." Yeah... smooth..
So much for Big Blue reliability... well, perception-wise that was a huge hit, but in the grand scheme of things, most of their drives were fine... and not subject to the "6 hour usage limit" the batch of "Deathstar" drives that went kaput on so many people.
Microsoft would've publicly added to the "free" RRoD repairs the addendum that people shouldn't be marathoning this "new and advanced hardware"...
Keep your console out in the open where air (COOL air) can get to it, and don't stuff a sock in the heat exchanger. This holds true for anyone's console... PS3/360 (pre/post heatsink repair)... Do this, and I bet your frustration level will diminish... and you won't have to curse Monkey-Boy Ballmer's name onto the wind...