I enjoyed this show more than I was expecting although that blue lighting completely killed the whole "different" look they were going for with the set. It obscured the brick design on the ramp, the bricks on the set, and was just distracting. They made it look different enough with the black ropes and black logo-less turnbuckle pads - the blue lighting was overkill and made it very hard to see the actual color of guys' gear because it was damned overpowering. I
ing hate this lighting setup and can't wait for them to nix it. Seriously, how ridiculous is it going to look when they try to sell DVDs of this thing or show highlight reels of it later and you can barely make anything out because THE SCREEN IS BATHED IN BLUE LIGHT.
Anyway, onto the show itself. The opener was a lot of fun - it had the comedy dance off, Kid Kash (with tons of tats and a slight gut) doing a dive, and Guido doing something he rarely did in ECW - WINNING. So I loved that. Simon's problem apparently involves too many carbs and too little exercise because he was among the portlier guys on the show. The guy never had the best body, but he now has love handles and looked so bad that Taz of all people, who came out looking like Viscera with his big puffy shirt, knocked him for looking so out of shape. Tracy Smothers dancing and doing his kung fu chops RULED.
2 Cold vs. CW Anderson was better than I was expecting because Scorpio looked better here than he did against Kash at the June '05 Hardcore Homecoming show (last time I remember seeing him work), and for a guy in his mid-40s, he moves around really well. I wouldn't mind him getting signed to TNA in the same kind of role Johnny B Badd had in '04 - random partner to young guys who could use a veteran to help get them over.
Blue Meanie sending in a video, but not actually being there, leading to The Blue Tillie playing his part was somewhat strange. They hung a lampshade on it by having Snow knock them for doing it, but man was Tillie a bad Blue Meaning impersonator. Chuckled at the BW2.0 shirt and Stevie wearing Dr. Stevie shorts long after the gimmick died and he never wore them during it, on an ECW reunion show. Stevie was in great shape and PJ Polaco moved around well. This was a decent little match here - nothing special, but nothing bad, and again, I liked seeing a guy who rarely won the big one in ECW win here as Stevie pinned with the Stevie Kick.
Rhino vs. Runt vs. Snow sure was a random grouping, and the match wasn't very good either. Runt coming out in the tie dye ruled. Snow hasn't aged a day in ten years, although him being on this show is somewhat funny since he was only in ECW while under a WWF contract in '98. He was only there for a few months and yet is one of the best-remembered acts in the group's history, which speaks well for both him and how much of an impact he made in that short time.
3D vs. Axl and Kahoneys was something else. Balls's name change ruled - it fits him perfectly, although it came out of nowhere because within the past year or so, when he did a cameo, the "Balls" name was fine. Oh well, it doesn't hurt him at all. This had chairs, flaming tables, light sabers, and Joel Gertner doing his awesome ring intros and lewd jokes. This was a lot of fun, and then the Gangstas came out to what I think was "Natural Born Killaz" being played on a kazoo and hit them with stuff. Then they all no-sold it and hugged. Very silly but mostly enjoyable aside from the hard shots to the head.
Raven vs. Dreamer was mostly bad, although it had some neat spots. The barb wire crossface to Raven, ala Dreamer having one done to him by CW with a table's support metal, was good, and I loved the handcuff DDT finish. All the head shots, not so much. Sure, it fit into this being the final showdown, and "the chairshot heard around the world", but it's 2010 and there's no need for chairshots to the skull anymore given all that is known now that wasn't known then about what kind of issues they can cause. Dreamer bringing his little daughters out to see him get all
ed up and traumatized was just stupid and disturbing. Mick being involved here was the saddest thing on the show - this man MAIN EVENTED WRESTLEMANIA and now he's working as a special ref on a second-rate ECW tribute show in 2010. This is what his career has come to.
RVD-Sabu was a very pleasant surprise. I had low expectations for it due to their Botchamania classic ladder match from '06. Sabu hit everything perfectly, RVD looked strong and hit things snuggly and actually covered Sabu really quickly after the five star as opposed to doing his goofy oversell. I'm not really sure how many more matches of this quality Sabu has in him, but I hope he gets some kind of good faith contract from someone based on this.
Now, with that said, all the TNA cameos came off as really forced. I'm sure it was done to give people PPV paydays that they lost out on due to giving the ECW guys PPV spots, but still, these things took up way too much time and came off as either complete bullshit, filler, or both. Francine's video from home was really sweet and it was nice to see that at least one person from ECW was able to let the past stay in the past. The big block of text tribute to the deceased was just weird. They didn't name anyone, and Every Word Was Capitalized Like This and that also looked bad. Lord knows they had plenty of time to kill, so I don't know why they couldn't just find photos of guys and do a photo tribute. Hardcore Homecoming did one in '05 and it came off far better than this.
The show-closing deal was a nice feel-good moment for me until DIXIE CARTER came out. I know that in storyline, she's the reason this is happening, but seriously, DIXIE CARTER AS THE SAVIOR OF ECW was worse than Steph. At least Steph had some presence - Dixie looked awkward even holding the beer, and then instead of focusing on the guys who this show was apparently dedicated to, we're treated to Bubba parading her around ringside after she was already took center stage in the ring.
TNA Pays Tribute To - People