[quote name='Strell']I think the problem the detractors are hitting on is that this first episode was actually really complicated to follow.
It goes from the accident -> rabies -> fun run. That's an incredible stretch, worthy of the recent schlock of Simpsons, where Bart might find a rabbit in the woods, and then later, own his own used car lot. (I don't believe this has actually happened in the Simpsons, as I do not watch the trash that is labeled as such these days, but you get the idea of the overwhelming amount of disconnect between the beginning and the end. But I bet it's going to happen now.)
My experience with tv shows is that the more complicated the episodes have to get, the worse the show itself becomes. If you watch season 1 of the Office, already there's a huge difference in how the show is generally laid out and executed versus seasons 2 and 3. In my opinion that's a pretty short amount of time to already be noticing a lot of drastic change, even if it's nothing more than series of minor changes. All of that adds up, and ultimately changes the show for better or worse.
And usually the best indicator is seeing how much more complex the plots have to get in order to bring you something new.
A good example (I'm sure there are many others) is Spongebob. In the beginning, the episodes have these really simple plots. "Spongebob can't remember how to make a Krabby Patty." That's it. Now the episodes move so quickly and are full of explanations and lots of "here's how we got to here, and here's how we are getting to there" text going on.
So when you've got something morphing from simple, straightforward premises into multi-layered "this only works because you saw the 8 things leading up to it" sorts of events, that's how I usually gauge whether or not a show is deteriorating. Maybe this is all personal opinion, but that's how I've always seen it. And usually when I really like something, I notice how the later episodes tend to fall apart compared to earlier stuff simply because of this ravenous need to be more complex. It's the whole "we have to continually wow our audience and keep them guessing" syndrome. It's hard to top something that is always so good, and that's a problem because there's always going to be a disconnection between the ability of the writers to do that and match it with the high expectations an audience will come to have.
A parallel to this is when you start seeing certain staples go by the wayside. The only real example I have right now is Jim's decreasing amount of pranks on Dwight. While I could see that getting old, not having it seems out of place and a little empty. Besides, the pranks were always so perfectly executed, I can't see someone getting sick of them. This might be a little bit of an exaggeration on my part.
I don't think this is happening just yet with the Office. If every episode ends up being this convoluted, then yeah, there's a problem. And if all the episodes start to focus heavily on relationships, then that's not so much a problem as it is a further deviation from the original premise of the show. But it's too early to tell. Season 3 had arguably some of the best stuff in the series yet, so I'm willing to wait.
Besides, there's still a huge amount of stuff I really enjoy.[/QUOTE]
I think I see where you're coming from, but the show became a lot more complicated in the 2nd and 3rd seasons because of the side characters and their interactions. I think that worked for the betterment of the show. It's also one of the reasons why I'm glad the UK Office only lasted a couple of seasons. A show has to evolve on a certain level to develop. Hell, Seinfeld changed a lot IMO, but in very subtle ways.
But that's not compelxity of the story line, like you are talking about. I didn't find the story to be that far off from what we've seen before. I didn't see a problem with the plausibility of it all, just the execution and the unfunniness (is that a word?) of it all. For instance, the scene visting Meredith in the hospital just wasn't that funny. It could have been cut and the episode would have been better for it. Same thing with that long segment on animals. It just wasn't very good. I felt like the deleted scenes were placed in to make it an hour long.
This last episode just left a bad taste in my mouth. I know it will get better, so I'm not worried about it. I just thought it was a sub par episode that looked 10x worse since it was the much hyped premiere.