[quote name='Mr Unoriginal']I've never gotten anything but pristine games from Gamefly.[/QUOTE]
I definitely don't doubt that. I've ordered about 12 games, and I'd say 8 were severely chipped/scratched, 2 were fairly scratched, and 2 were pretty good (but definitely not pristine). I didn't realize the condition of the discs could be so bad based on most people's great comments of disc quality so I was quite a bit disappointed when my first order of 5 games showed up in horrible condition. Since then, I've just taken disc condition into consideration when evaluating whether or not the price is good for me. I'm admittedly picky about disc condition, and only buy used if it's a game I'm unsure about, or the price is too good to pass up.