[quote name='Glass_Ghost_0']Alright I have 1,200 points on one account and 1,600 on another. What do you guys recommend that I get out of what's on sale. This includes Bully if it's still 1,200[/QUOTE]
I think "Bully" is a great choice, and yes, it's still only $14.99 / 1200pts, which is why I've left it in the OP. Used copies @ GameStop/BB are still in the $30's, so I'm not assuming it's a permanent markdown until MS says it's so.
Otherwise, the game-critics' darlings are Spelunky, Bastion, Castle Crashers, Shadow Complex, and of course, GeoWars.