[quote name='Kelegacy']They weren't hurting anyone, they were offering a great service, for a great price, and made lots of people happy. Just because they emailed the codes directly instead of putting them in a physical mailbox doesn't red flag "bad guy" to me. I don't even see what the problem is, honestly. Sour people (for whatever reason) always seem to spoil the fun of others. It's in their nature.
I can't invision a person getting a great XBLA game for half off and then saying, "You know what, this isn't right--this violates ebay policy so I guess I should report them."[/QUOTE]
It was 2&2 that ratted them out. Thanks a lot.
Also, they were hurting someone. The evidence (or, rather, the deductions) points to illegally-acquired credit cards or some form of payment, which in turn were used to buy the codes full-price on Amazon.com and sold for cheaper to everyone else, but still turning out a profit. It was, in a sense, promoting criminal activity. But, now that they're gone, who knows where the money is going to know, or what is being purchased.. something is still going on, right?