[quote name='whoknows']There's being difficult and being difficult in the wrong way, and having to repeat a whole level because you died is difficult in the wrong way IMO.
I mean, once again take DMC, in 4 if you wanted you could restart where you died, but lose all the points you've gained up to that point, but it let you restart at say...a boss fight that could still easily destroy you over and over and over again, even though you were restarting right at it. That lets you get better at the part where you're having trouble without having to repeat the level all over again in order to retry the part where you need practice, and eventually you'll be good enough to beat the whole level, including the boss without dying.[/QUOTE]
This is partially true. But in Demon's Souls, going through the level again did 2 things for you -- it tuned your mechanics and it gave you souls. Souls you could use to level up. To help you with that boss. It'd be the same way in DMC if DMC didn't have a checkpoints, keep playing til you can combo like a fiend and style like a mother
er and meanwhile, you'll earn a ton of xp to use in getting more life or stronger moves or better abilities.
And if you think the levels in Demon's Souls are long, you're doing something wrong. The game had checkpoints already (sorta), in that you got a new section/waypoint of a world to start at after a section's boss. But that's besides the point. A speed run of the game can be done in less than 2 hours. I've done it when I needed rare stones in world 4-3 to reappear so I could get my platinum. When I got tired of grinding, I beat the game, started again, then enemies were harder/more aggressive/basically 1-hit kills, but between knowing the game mechanics and the worlds, I was back at the end of world 4-3 in approximately 20 minutes.
A large majority of the game is taking the time to learn the worlds and learn the mechanics... the first time takes forever, because you are afraid of everything and afraid of losing souls. A large amount of the game time (120 hours for my platinum) was grinding levels or grinding rare stones. Granted, I was a dick and fought back against the game any way I could. Stealth kill of the boss of 1-4 -- using obstacles against flamelurker in 2-2 -- using the hit and run blindspot against the boss of 4-2, etc.