[quote name='Corvin']It was an off-the-cuff comment for joke purposes.

Bush was alright but the way I see how music has progressed since the early nineties is kinda like the movie
Multiplicity. It just gets dumber and dumber as it goes.
Go with me on this one:
PJ, AIC, Nirvana, STP & Soundgarden(Seattle)* spawn acts like >> Bush & Silverchair** which in turn spawn >> Creed*** which leads us to today and >> Nickelback****
*Doug
**competent clone of Doug but still not as good as the original
***sensitive clone of Doug
****childish and mildly-retarded clone of Doug
No offense to anyone who likes these acts. All in good fun and just a fun analogy to toss out there.
Speaking of, personally I love Silverchair, but I'm not deaf. If you listen to those first few albums they were essentially PJlite. They have actually turned themselves into quite decent artists (although I've always enjoyed them).
Young Modern(2007) was an incredible album.[/quote]
Wow, glad I checked back in on this since it has sparked a bit of discussion. I can appreciate what Pearl Jam did (personally, I feel they're indebted to Nirvana though...who was superior). Your "Michael Keaton Theory" definitely holds water though, as most of what you said was accurate. But I'll say, in 1993, I was 11, and Pearl Jam just didn't have the appeal to me that Nirvana did. As I got older, I could enjoy them more, but they still just didn't draw me in past their big hits: Even Flow, Jeremy, Alive...and even Black, which is a song that I love.
But when Bush came along, they took a formula that was rough and messy, and made it a bit more coherent. I don't think Bush is better than Nirvana in any way, but their songs definitely hit home with me far more than Pearl Jam. I can appreciate Pearl Jam melodically, but hearing Eddie slur his way through a song like a drunken lunatic never did much for me. I'm a singer/songwriter, so lyrics tend to be a big deal for me. I'll just leave it at that though, as not to upset the balance here. But it's just my opinion and personal preference.